Conversation
The problem with apple tier lists is that people rank apples using Red Delicious as a baseline, when someone says Honeycrisp or SweeTango are 10/10 it's because they do what RDs are supposed to but better. I love apples but what I want most of all is sour, like my baseline is Granny Smith and because of that GS is my #1 just because there are no other big name strains that do what it does well.
1
0
1

shroomie/joan (of the agaric system)

@AppleAmps i have unfortunate news: the granny smith is bad https://applerankings.com/granny-smith-apple-review/

1
0
0
@shroomie
See, but that's exactly my point! Look at their rankings for sour apples specifically and it's at the top, beaten only by a Belgian specialty apple.
1
0
0

shroomie/joan (of the agaric system)

@AppleAmps oh i thought it was like. in last place

1
0
1

shroomie/joan (of the agaric system)

@AppleAmps i remember it being in last place

2
0
1

shroomie/joan (of the agaric system)

@AppleAmps yeah if you look at the numbers its number is the smallest

1
0
1
@shroomie
Overall it's like, exactly middle of the pack but for sours it's second. Fourth technically but counting only officially reviewed apples it's second.
1
0
1
@shroomie
Yeah but I'm pretty sure the number is how it does in general.
1
0
1

shroomie/joan (of the agaric system)

@AppleAmps well yeah but in the specific category of “sour apples” its beaten by kanzi, king david, braeburn, lucy glo, pink pearl, wild twist, and pink lady

1
0
1

shroomie/joan (of the agaric system)

@AppleAmps i mean i’m a fellow sour apple lover but i haven’t had any of the alternatives lol

1
0
1

shroomie/joan (of the agaric system)

@AppleAmps i mean granny smith lover. i love granny smiths. they’re the best. fire ass MLP character too

0
0
1
@shroomie
And again that's counting two unranked apples, it SHOULD be second.
1
0
1

shroomie/joan (of the agaric system)

1
0
0
@shroomie
But that's what I'm telling you! In the sour apple rankings the number doesn't matter because it tells you how it does in the overall rankings, if you're judging it just as a sour apple all that matters is how high up it is!!
1
0
1

shroomie/joan (of the agaric system)

@AppleAmps i only kinda get this????

0
0
1